Confessions from the Mud: Eco-Anxiety and the Power of Surprise
A special bonus episode mini-series from Climate Changed
In this third of four installments of our special bonus mini-series, Climate Changed returns to the 2025 BTS Center Convocation. Over the last few weeks, we have heard from participants who “flipped the script”—stepping away from data and policy to share personal, lived experiences of the climate crisis.
In this episode, co-hosts Peterson Toscano and Ben Yosua-Davis introduce two more stories – this time from Kate André and Blair A. R. Nelsen. These stories explore the power of honesty and surprise, taking us from a muddy riverbank in Massachusetts to a support group room where nothing is quite what it seems.
Peterson and Ben also break down the specific storytelling techniques—The Confession and The Twist—that make these narratives so effective, while storytelling coach Cheryl Hamilton and previous guest Tyler Mark Nelson return to discuss how one person’s story can “unlock” the stories of others.
About This Mini-Series: Convocation Stories
At the 2025 BTS Center Convocation, participants were invited to share climate-centered stories grounded in their own lives. Working with coaches from Stellar Story Company, these storytellers moved beyond the “doom and gloom” binary to find humor, resilience, and spiritual insight in the face of a changing world.
Next Steps
- Share this episode with a friend or your faith community. As Cheryl and Tyler remind us, “Stories unlock stories.”
- Tell your own story. You don’t need a stage. Share a reflection on social media or record a voice memo for a friend.
- Contact us. Share your reflections by email at podcast@thebtscenter.org or leave a voicemail at 207-200-6986.
- Learn more about The BTS Center and upcoming programs at TheBTSCenter.org.
-
Meet Our Hosts
After spending 17 years and over $30,000 on three continents attempting to “de-gay” himself through conversion therapy, Peterson Toscano came out a quirky queer Quaker concerned with human rights. He asks himself and his audiences unusual questions: Who are the gender outlaws in the Bible? What is a queer response to climate change? What is the role of comedy when addressing trauma? His film, Transfigurations—
Ben Yosua-Davis serves on The BTS Center staff team as Director of Applied Research, where he shapes the organization’s posture of “rigorous and reverent curiosity,” focused on research that supports and shares the wisdom of on-the-ground practitioners working in a climate-changed world. He is a graduate of Drew Theological Seminary and Colby College.
Previously, he lived in Haverhill, MA, where he co-planted a new church called The Vine, one of the earliest mainline missional church expressions in the country, and hosted a podcast entitled, “Reports From the Spiritual Frontier,” which chronicled the day-to-day lives of leaders innovating new forms of spiritual community.
Ben is a Maine native and now lives on Chebeague Island, Maine with his wife, Melissa, his son Michael, and his daughters, Genevieve and Emeline; where he directs the community chorus and delivers tins of cookies to unsuspecting neighbors.
Meet The Storytellers
Kate André serves as Pastor of the Mennonite Congregation of Boston and is the Mennonite/Anabaptist Chaplain at Harvard University. In her story, Kate uses the power of “confession” to admit that, despite her work in creation care, she wasn’t always a nature lover. She takes us on a journey from the comfort of dark movie theaters to the muddy reality of planting hope, showing us that we don’t have to be perfect environmentalists to do good work.
Blair A. R. Nelsen is the Executive Director of Waterspirit and represents the Congregation of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Peace at the United Nations. Bringing a global perspective from her time living in Venezuela and Brazil, Blair shares a story about seeking help for eco-anxiety. Expecting to find a room full of despairing peers, she instead encounters a “twist” that reveals the deep, intergenerational resilience found in community.
Cheryl Hamilton is the Founder and Executive Director of Stellar Story Company. An award-winning communications expert, Cheryl has coached over 1,500 people from 80 countries. In this episode, she shares insights on how stories can lead to unexpected connections and richer conversations.
Announcing Season Four of Climate Changed!
Season Four is coming soon! We are thrilled to welcome incoming co-hosts Nicole Diroff and Autumn Brown, who will explore what it means to live, love, and lead with faith and imagination in a climate-changed world.
Season Four Guests include:
- Francis Weller: Author of The Wild Edge of Sorrow.
- Norma Wong: Zen Master and leader at the Institute of Zen Studies.
- Rabbi Ora Nitkin-Kaner: Climate Change Chaplain.
- Tory Stevens: Climate Narrative Project.
- Katie Mears: Episcopal Relief & Development.
Make sure you are subscribed so you don’t miss the Season Four premiere!

